Demo leagueSimulated from real historical player data. Not an observed league.

Colleen Murphy

7 seasonsScouting report as of today, full career and not this season alone.

Avg finish
7.7
Titles
0
First position
RB rd 1.0
New keepers
83% fresh each year

The single clearest signal Colleen Murphy brings to the draft table is an early, heavy commitment to running backs that does not relent until the roster is full. Every year across seven drafts, the first pick has been a running back, and the middle rounds continue loading the position — running backs account for more than half of all picks in rounds one through three and nearly half in rounds four through six. Wide receivers absorb most of what is left in those same rounds, which means the first ten picks are almost entirely split between two positions. If you want a specific running back or wide receiver who projects into the middle of the board, plan to move for them before Murphy does, because that window closes early.

The quarterback and tight end slots are filled late and without urgency. The typical first quarterback arrives in round eight and the typical first tight end in round ten, and those figures have held steady across the most recent five seasons as well — there is no sign of a shift. That consistency means Murphy is not a competitor for elite tight ends or early quarterbacks, and those positions will be available longer than they would be against a manager who values them earlier. The late-round tail of the draft goes almost entirely to receivers, running backs, and the kicker and defense slots, leaving little room for positional experimentation.

The roster Murphy finishes a season with is remarkably close to the one drafted — turnover between the drafted roster and the final roster has been low across all seven seasons, and the recent five seasons show no meaningful change in that rate. Keepers cycle through quickly as well, with more than four in five keeper slots starting a fresh streak rather than continuing one, and no player has been held longer than two consecutive seasons. The practical implication is that the players Murphy drafts are largely the players Murphy plays, so the draft itself is the primary roster-building event — there is little evidence of significant reshaping after the board closes.

One consistent thread running through the draft history is a pull toward players from the San Francisco and Dallas organizations, each appearing in five or more of seven drafts, with the San Francisco connection extending into every one of the five most recent seasons. The Georgia college pipeline is also a genuine signal rather than a base-rate coincidence — eight picks against a league-seat average of roughly four, spread across five of seven drafts, with six of those picks coming in the last five seasons alone. Neither pattern changes the positional calculus above, but if a San Francisco skill player or a Georgia-pedigreed prospect is on the board in the middle rounds, Murphy's history suggests they will not last.

How they finish

across 7 seasons

Average finish
7.7
Field-adjusted
22%
Titles
0
Top-3 finishes
0
Best
5 of 10 (2020)
Worst
10 of 10 (2022)
Average points
1,640
Record
35-68-0 (7 seasons)
Best points season
1,790.6 (2020)
Volatility
23%
Current run
bottom half in last 5 seasons

Draft behavior: snake

across 7 seasons

Typical first pick at each position

  • RBround 1
  • WRround 2
  • QBround 8
  • TEround 10
  • DEFround 15
  • Kround 16

Picks per draft

  • WR6.3
  • RB6
  • QB1.9
  • TE1.1
  • DEF1
  • K1

Where they draft from

across 7 seasons

Average slot
#4.1
Earliest ever
#1
Latest ever
#6

Seasons at each slot

  • #32 seasons
  • #52 seasons
  • #62 seasons
  • #11 season

2019: #5 · 2020: #3 · 2021: #6 · 2022: #3 · 2023: #1 · 2024: #6 · 2025: #5

Positional runs

across 7 seasons

Joins runs
25% (league 24%)
Starts runs
15% (league 16%)

Joined a positional run on 26 of 106 picks; set one off on 16 of 107. Keeper slots excluded.

Rookie appetite

across 7 seasons

Rookies drafted
8
Share of picks
8% (league 12%)

Rookie status known for 96% of picks in the 7 covered drafts.

QB stacks

across 7 seasons

Drafts with a stack
3 of 7 (league seat rate 33%)
Stacked pass-catchers
0.7 per draft

Teams stacked

  • 1 draft
  • 1 draft
  • 1 draft
  • 1 draft

A stack is a QB and a same-team WR/TE drafted in the same draft. Keeper slots excluded.

Players they keep coming back to

across 7 seasons

  • Darrell HendersonRB drafted in 2 of 7 drafts, kept 1 season (2019–2021)
  • 49ersDEF drafted in 1 of 7 drafts, kept 2 seasons (2021–2023)
  • Alvin KamaraRB drafted in 2 of 7 drafts (2020–2021)
  • Dalvin CookRB drafted in 2 of 7 drafts (2019–2023)
  • Davante AdamsWR drafted in 2 of 7 drafts (2020–2025)
  • David JohnsonRB drafted in 2 of 7 drafts (2019–2020)
  • David NjokuTE drafted in 2 of 7 drafts (2019–2025)
  • Elijah MitchellRB drafted in 2 of 7 drafts (2023–2024)
  • George KittleTE drafted in 2 of 7 drafts (2021–2022)
  • Javonte WilliamsRB drafted in 2 of 7 drafts (2022–2024)
  • Justin JeffersonWR drafted in 2 of 7 drafts (2020–2023)
  • Mecole HardmanWR drafted in 2 of 7 drafts (2020–2021)

Counted against 7 drafts on record. Drafting and keeping are separate decisions.

Teams they draft from

across 7 seasons

  • 6 of 7 drafts · 7 picks
  • 5 of 7 drafts · 7 picks · up to 3 in one draft
  • 5 of 7 drafts · 9 picks · up to 3 in one draft
  • 5 of 7 drafts · 7 picks
  • 4 of 7 drafts · 4 picks
  • 4 of 7 drafts · 6 picks · up to 3 in one draft

Keeper slots excluded. Only fresh draft picks count.

Colleges they draft from

across 7 seasons

  • 8 picks · 5 of 7 drafts · league seat avg 3.8
  • 4 picks · 3 of 7 drafts · league seat avg 1.7
  • 3 picks · 3 of 7 drafts · league seat avg 1.2

College known for 96% of picks in the 7 covered drafts.

Keepers

across 6 seasons

Kept per season
2.0
Average tenure
1.2 seasons
Longest hold
2 seasons
New keepers
83%

Keepers by position

  • RB42%
  • DEF25%
  • WR25%
  • K8%

Roster churn

across 7 seasons

Roster turnover
11%
Drafted
17.3
Still there at season's end
15.4

Share of the drafted roster no longer on the roster at season's end.

Every rival in your league has a page like this

This dossier was written from a simulated league’s seven seasons. Yours would be written from the real thing: paste your league’s draft history and RotoAlpha writes the book on every rival. The rival report is free.

Get the book on your rivals
RotoAlpha
Signing you in…